Break All The Rules ... and paint it Black!
It is no surprise that I have an ongoing affinity for the color black. It is also, equally expected that my dream job would basically be curating historical properties and ‘restoring’ them to their former glory. I love all things old house, no matter the era, if it’s “old” it is a treasure to clarify, I have nothing against a newer home, it’s just not as much my jam.
In the world of interior design, and more specifically the world of historical design, there is a constant discussion on ‘restoration’ vs. ‘renovation’. Which is appropriate, which is right vs. wrong, and correctly identifying it is that you are hoping to accomplish and what it is, you are in fact, doing.
Generally, “renovation”’s broad stroke includes anything being done to a property that wasn’t there before. Think HGTV let’s make this an open floor plan approach. You would likely consider yourself renovating if your focus is creating a space based on your modern needs with little regard for maintaining what was there. While you would guess that I consider this blasphemy which I would agree with the truth is, in many instances this is the case.
If you speak to someone about their home and they refer to their quest as a restoration you know you have found a purist. Their primary goal is to restore what was there before. Think original everything. From millwork, to paint color to lighting fixtures. Homeowners that have set a goal for restoration want to take their property back to the state most similar to that at its conception. While I personally believe that these angels have a special place in heaven, it is a great undertaking and commitment and not always what a modern human may want.
What if you fall in the middle? What if the goals you have for your home don’t align with either goal? You may deeply care about maintaining the integrity of the home, but also have your heart set on a very modern chandelier and can lighting. In those cases I say throw caution to the wind and break all the rules!
Designing a home is such a unique and individual undertaking. I often spend countless meetings with clients listening to what they are saying, but also observing what they are doing. My goal is always to provide a space that is 100% them. Creating what was there before, while noble, fails to allow the current occupant a chance to build upon that story. Homes are like trees, they should last longer than us. We are a blimp in their history. But that doesn’t mean you should not be allowed to stake your spot in their story.
It is important to the home and your harmonious relationship with it to find the happy medium between renovating and restoring. It is your responsibility to honor any space you inhabit. There is history in the walls, tales that were told, and stories that deserve to be remembered. You have a responsibility to value those parts. But you are a part of that story as well.
3 ways to break the rules with respect
Play with paint!
Paint is just that, paint. It is an easy change, and an easy fix if it needs to be adjusted down the road.
Artwork.
Any designer would tell you that art is a must in any completed space. Bringing in art that speaks to you will keep your space feeling reflective of your own unique style.
Switch up the style.
I LOVE LOVE LOVE mixing genres of furnishings. My 1908 dining room has original paneling, mid-century captain chairs and acrylic dining chairs. Using your furnishings as the exchangeable characteristics of the room will ensure you don’t create something too permanent.
Ultimately, there are no rules. Preferences, of course, but rules are meant to be broken, so break them. Be sympathetic to your home’s history but don’t forget to include yourself. What drives your design decisions in your older home?